Those who can, do. Those who want to learn, evaluate.

As an aspiring writer in middle school, I took a writing course one summer. (Yes, middle school. Yes, summer. I was a nerd. I’m still a nerd. It’s served me well.) Use imagery, my brilliant instructor said, but be sure not to mix metaphors. Use adjectives sparingly, and make them count. Eschew adverbs altogether. Keep the cadence interesting by mixing long and short sentences. And on and on and on.

I’d like to think my writing got better over that summer. But it wasn’t until I hit college that those lessons truly sank in. No, it wasn’t the skilled professors or the dozens of research papers. It was the fact that I was hired as a writing tutor. Having to read other student’s work – and groan through their myriad bad practices, or fly through the occasional well written piece – was what made all those lessons sink in. Seeing what sabotaged other people’s writing, or what made it work, allowed me to be a better appraiser of my own output.  To wit, if you want to become better at something, get yourself in a position to evaluate it.

I’ve always considered myself to be descent at job applications and interviews, but when I had the opportunity to be the one making hiring decisions, I gained a whole new level of understanding and appreciation for the process. (Yes, we really do only glance at your resume and cover letter; and yes, we do somehow manage to notice your gross errors in those few seconds).  In reviewing articles, I gained a better sense of what works for scholarly submissions. I’ve never had a chance to evaluate grants, but those who have tell me it’s a game-changing opportunity.

A certain level of competence is usually required to be allowed access to the evaluating sphere. But you don’t have to be a pro or an expert. You just have to be willing to seize the opportunities that come by. So say yes to that offer to be part of the accreditation panel, or the budget review committee, or the program evaluation team. Sign up to be a discussant at conferences. Wiggle your way into the hiring or promotion committee. If you want to improve, evaluate your options – then start evaluating.


3 thoughts on “Those who can, do. Those who want to learn, evaluate.

  1. I have to say that I found your article quite interesting. You have opened my eyes up to different venues that I would like to pursue with further exploration. Thank you for your thoughts.


  2. Anita,

    Thanks for your comment, and for expanding the discussion. You are right — informal “evaluative” activities occur constantly. There is something to be said for formal situations where hopefully the evaluator gets some parameters/mentoring/insights on what the profession is looking for, but every chance to look over someone else’s grant application, PowerPoint presentation, speech, budget analysis, etc. is an opportunity to evaluate and learn. (And all this time, we thought it was just drudgery!) Sitting at meetings where a program is forming, being evaluated, or modified is another evaluative opportunity. There is boundless (and free! and highly applicable!) growth to be obtained from casting a critical eye on our activities and the activities of others.


  3. I completely agree and suspect that most people don’t realize that they engage in “evaluative” activities every day and that the opportunities described here are simply formalized situations where evaluation is intentional.

    I believe that if people took this advice perhaps they would gain (or refresh) some of the critical thinking skills that are so important in today’s chaotic media environment and in the battles we wage in public administration for legitimacy and respect.


Tell Us What You Think

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s